whisk or shake

In an early post I said I did not think it made a difference whether you whisked or shook the dressing. WRONG! - at least when one of the ingredients is honey -- it does not shake -- and if you have used a narrow mouthed bottle, believe me, you are in trouble -- it is very difficult (read impossible) to get even a very small whisk (or fork) in there -- use a bowl -- and whisk.